Surrey need a big big broom.
No one is sure whether Alan Butcher is even the man to wield it yet.
There is so much dead wood in their roster, and getting in Arjantha Mendis or Brett Lee isn’t going to help.
Once they have a functioning roster they can worry about a big name international.
So lets look at who stays or who goes.
Batting
Ramps – He bats ok, but doesn’t look much chop as a captain, so that job may have to go to someone else. Stay.
Butcher – Still makes the runs, deserves loyalty from Surrey, but should not expect to be captain next year. Stay.
Afzaal – All things considered had a good year, but in a good side should be your 6th best batsman. Needs to make centuries not 50s. Stay.
Newman – Averaged 42, and is a good opening batsman. Like Afzaal needs to convert way more often. Stay.
Batty – A wicket keeper that makes 2 tons a year is pretty handy. You wouldn’t get rid of him. Stay.
Spreigel – A young player with a lot of promise, worth keeping as a young allrounder, but needs to make big scores next year or find a new county. Stay.
Benning – 35 first class games and an average of 32. Not top 5 material, but with Spreigel and Jordan playing you could almost play him at 6, but it’s a risk, Give him one more season. Stay.
Walters – 5 games no scores of any note. Is 25, so maybe too early to call, but from what I have seen is never going to be a top order player, and Surrey don’t need to keep more middle order players who can average 30 around. Go.
Jordan – Is a foetus, must keep him. But lets not indulge him too much. Stay.
Murtagh – Looked out of his depth against Kent, but he does look like a fighter, and seems the most likely to open with Newman. If Surrey bring in a gun opener, he may be shown the door, I’d keep him around, but he wouldn’t be first team. Stay.
Bowling
Saqlain – Old grey mare she aint what she used to be. 38 wickets at 33, they need a spinner who averages less than 30, he either needs to step up, or… Stay, just.
Dernbach – Is still young enough to come good, and is probably the most promising bowler at Surrey, and the second best performer this year. Stay.
Tudor – Can’t see how any team could get back into division one with Tudor in their attack. His record this year isn’t bad, but he just rally isn’t that good. Go.
Collins – His record may not show it, but I think Collins was unlucky this year. I think he should be back next year, he tested the better opposition batsman. I think he can help Surrey out. Stay.
Ormond – He was a good bowler back in the day, but I think his best is behind him. Sorry Jimmy, but I can’t see him helping Surrey back to division one. Go.
Schofield – Go.
Coach
Butcher – Go or stay, flip a coin. He can only coach the team that is there, the person should go is the academy coach, and the head recruiter. But Butcher will probably go.
Guys who are already gone.
Ahktar- like he was ever here.
Nicholson – has a great batting record for a bowler.
Brown – statistically must be unlucky to miss out.
What Surrey need.
A stock bowling seamer, someone who can lock up an end for 10 overs and only cough up 16 runs. Tim Murtagh would be ideal, anyway to get him back with his brother.
A dead set wicket taker, any kind of bowler is great, but they need someone who can take 60+ wickets in a year. Buy him, or steal him, but you need a person who takes wickets like you and i yawn.
A captain. Someone who can captain his ass off, but more importantly someone who can bring on the guys like Roy, Spreigel, Jordan, and Benning. They need a Warne/Fleming type.
Conclusion.
The batting works, but they need the ability to make 20 wickets a game, and someone who can rally the troops.
Also they need a mascot that is better than a dog.
And a press box you can see the cricket from.